Rome's burn-your-fingers cutlets — eaten too hot to hold, on purpose

Scottadito means "finger-burner", and Roman trattorias have never apologised for it. The dish is a dare as much as a recipe: cutlets marinated in olive oil, lemon and rosemary, grilled hard until blistered, and eaten straight off the grill with your hands while they're genuinely too hot to hold comfortably. No cutlery, no ceremony, plenty of napkins. It's lamb at its most joyful — and at home it's an hour of marinating, ten minutes of fierce heat, and four bones picked absolutely clean. Feeds two, though nobody's ever accused it of being polite.

1 hr 20 mins 2 servings Prep 1 hr 10 minsCook 10 minsMain CourseItalian

Ingredients

  • 4 Your Farmer grass-fed lamb cutlets (1 pack)
  • 3 tbsp olive oil
  • 1 lemon — zest and juice of half, the rest in wedges
  • 2 cloves garlic, smashed with the flat of a knife
  • 2 sprigs rosemary, lightly bruised
  • Freshly ground black pepper
  • Sea salt flakes, for after grilling

Instructions

For the marinade

Lay the cutlets in a shallow dish. Pour over the olive oil, lemon zest and juice, and add the smashed garlic, bruised rosemary and a generous grind of pepper. Turn everything to coat.

4 lamb cutlets3 tbsp olive oil2 cloves garlic2 sprigs rosemary

Cover and marinate in the fridge for 1 hour, turning once halfway. No salt yet — it goes on at the end, Roman style.

For the grill

Take the cutlets out of the fridge 15 minutes before cooking. Heat a grill pan over the highest heat your stove owns until it's properly smoking — scottadito doesn't work over a timid flame.

Lift the cutlets from the marinade, letting the excess drip off, and pick away any clinging garlic or rosemary so it doesn't burn bitter on the pan.

Grill 2 minutes per side — hard, fast and undisturbed — until blistered and deeply browned outside and pink at the bone. Work in two batches if your pan crowds.

Scatter immediately with sea salt flakes and pile onto a warm platter with the lemon wedges.

sea salt flakeslemon wedges

Serve straight away and eat with your fingers, holding the bone — the whole point is that they hit the table too hot to hold politely. Bread, a bitter leaf salad and something cold to drink complete the job.

Appears in

In every lamb share — Cutlets (4 pack)

Your Farmer CSA grass-fed lamb share — Pack B selection of pasture-raised lamb cuts, vacuum-sealed, NSW & ACT delivery
CSA Pastured Lamb Share
Sale price From $150.00Regular price $162.41

The Cut That Made the Dish Possible

Scottadito only works because of what a cutlet is: a single rib off the rack, thin enough to cook through in four minutes, with a frenched bone that doubles as a handle. Thicker chops can't play this game — by the time the inside is done, the ritual of eating them scorching-hot off the grill has passed. Roman cooks worked this out generations ago with abbacchio, their young milk-fed lamb, and the recipe has never needed a second draft: oil, lemon, rosemary, fire, salt, fingers. The lamb itself carries the dish, which is exactly why it rewards good sourcing. Your Farmer® cutlets come from lambs raised on open pasture — four to a pack in every pasture-raised lamb share — and that grass-fed sweetness is what you taste when a recipe refuses to hide behind sauce. It's the same thinking behind how we farm: get the paddock right and the kitchen's job gets simple.

Swaps and Variations

Romans argue about the herb — rosemary is common, sage has its loyalists, and some houses use both. A pinch of dried chilli in the marinade is a southern touch that works. The barbecue does this even better than the stovetop if you have one going: same times, direct high heat, lid up. Lamb loin chops make a bigger-appetite version — marinate the same way and add 2 minutes a side — though you lose the elegant little handle that makes eating these so much fun. For a crowd, scale to two or three packs and grill in relays, sending each batch out the moment it's salted; scottadito waits for no one.

Storage and Leftovers

The cutlets can marinate up to 24 hours ahead, which actually suits entertaining — all that's left on the night is ten loud minutes at the stove. Cooked leftovers (a rare event with this dish) keep 3 days airtight in the fridge and are best eaten cold or flashed briefly in a hot pan; a gentle reheat just steams away the char. Sliced off the bone into a crusty roll with rocket and a rub of the leftover lemon, yesterday's scottadito makes a lunch worth guarding. When the pack's gone, reserve your share for the next delivery.

Frequently asked questions

What does scottadito actually mean?

It's Italian for "finger-burner" — from scottare (to scorch) and dito (finger). The dish is defined by being eaten by hand straight off the grill, while the bones are still almost too hot to hold.

Why does the salt go on after grilling instead of before?

It's the traditional Roman approach for this dish — flaky salt on the hot blistered crust right off the grill gives you little bursts of crunch and seasoning. The lemony marinade has already done the deeper seasoning work.

Can I barbecue these instead of using a grill pan?

Yes, and it's arguably the superior version — direct high heat, 2 minutes a side, and the open flame adds smoke a pan can't. Just watch for flare-ups as the marinade oil drips.

How do I serve scottadito for more than two people?

Allow one pack of four cutlets per two guests and grill in quick batches, salting and serving each round immediately rather than holding them back. It's a platter-in-the-middle, napkins-everywhere kind of meal.

0 commentson Lamb Cutlets Scottadito

Three Simple Steps

A whole table of real food.

Your Farmers grow grass-fed beef and lamb, pastured eggs and the best eco-grown veggies and produce — every item grown to the same ecological standard, every farmer one you can know by name. One subscription, your whole real-food shop.

01

Reserve your share — or try a pack

Subscribe to a share of the harvest, or start with a one-off fixed pack.

02

Make it your own

Pick your delivery rhythm and what's in the box. Skip or cancel anytime — no lock-in.

03

Cook, savour, know your farmer

We deliver in a reusable esky we collect next time. No couriers, no waste.

5.0
Vendor:Your Farmer

CSA Grass Fed Beef Share

Value $169.99
Price $152.00
Vendor:Your Farmer

CSA Pastured Lamb Share

Value $162.41
Price $150.00
Vendor:Your Farmer

"Tucker Box" Budget Beef Pack

Value $196.38
Price $186.00
Vendor:Your Farmer

“Steak King” Premium Beef Box

Value $157.43
Price $149.00
Vendor:Your Farmer

Grass-Fed Beef Sausages, Mince and Diced (SMD) Bundle Pack

Value $272.82
Price $218.00
Vendor:Your Farmer

"Mixed Grill King" Combo

Value $273.56
Price $260.00
Vendor:Your Farmer

"Slow King Beef" Combo

Value $147.43
Price $140.00
Vendor:Your Farmer

"Slow King Lamb" Combo

Value $147.43
Price $140.00
Vendor:Your Farmer

Bulk Grass-Fed Beef - Cut-up Your Way

Price $1,048.00
Vendor:Your Farmer

Bulk Pastured Full Lamb - Cut-up Your Way

Price $495.00

More Recipes

View all

Greek-style grass-fed lamb roast with lemon and oregano served over golden potatoes in a ceramic baking dish.

Greek-Style Lamb Roast with Lemon and Oregano

Lemon, oregano and time — the Greek family-table treatment for the whole cut

Every Greek family has a version of this and none of them are wrong. Garlic, dried oregano and lemon get worked deep into the lamb, potatoes go underneath to catch everything that falls, and the oven runs slow enough that nobody has to watch it. What comes out isn't pink, carve-at-the-table lamb — it's the other thing entirely: golden on top, giving underneath, with lemony potatoes that half the table will fight over harder than the meat. It's Sunday cooking from a country that takes Sundays seriously.

Read moreabout Greek-Style Lamb Roast with Lemon and Oregano

Low-and-slow barbecued grass-fed lamb ribs with a dry-rub bark, sliced on butcher's paper.

Low-and-Slow BBQ Lamb Ribs with Dry Rub

Paprika, brown sugar, patience — American barbecue discipline meets Australian lamb

This is the recipe for the day you've decided the barbecue is the afternoon's entertainment, not just the cooking appliance. No foil, no shortcuts: a paprika and brown sugar rub, a hooded barbecue held low around 140C, and three or so unhurried hours while the fat renders, the spice sets into proper bark and the smell slowly takes over the street. Lamb ribs suit the American low-and-slow treatment better than most people expect — they're smaller and fattier than pork ribs, so you get all the bark in less time. Pour something cold. This one's a sit-outside recipe.

Read moreabout Low-and-Slow BBQ Lamb Ribs with Dry Rub

Grilled grass-fed lamb chump chops sliced over a warm French-style lentil salad with mustard dressing.

Grilled Chump Chops with Warm Lentil Salad

Charred chops over mustardy lentils — the bistro order, made at home

Walk into any honest bistro in France and there'll be lamb with lentils somewhere on the board. It works because the two halves trade favours — earthy lentils soak up the lamb's resting juices, and a sharp Dijon dressing cuts the richness of a properly charred chop. The lentils simmer away on their own for twenty-five minutes while you see to the chops, so the timing looks after itself. Hearty without being heavy, smart enough for guests, and most of it comes from the pantry.

Read moreabout Grilled Chump Chops with Warm Lentil Salad